In politics, as in sports (and life), there is enormous power in being underestimated. It can be a kind of superpower. And I have a strong feeling that Donald Trump and the Republican Party have only begun to experience the potentially fatal consequences of underestimating Kamala Harris.
Many in the GOP leadership believed that they were on the verge of crushing what little political life remained in Joe Biden. Then, as the president dropped out of the race, Trump’s campaign strategists appeared to jump to the conclusion that Harris was the second-best thing. In their fever dreams, Harris was seen as a weak candidate who’d had everything in life handed to her on a DEI plate. Who reflected the most liberal dreams of San Francisco “radicals.” Who was kind of “out there.” (Note to Republicans: Check out Exhibit A, one J.D. Vance.)
But in politics, preconceptions can bite you pretty quickly. Harris has come out of the box roaring like a lion and is already blowing away expectations in terms of her personality, her performance, her discipline, her poll numbers, and her fundraising. And while observers have raised doubts about her management skills—and contend that she can be thin-skinned and overly defensive at times—I can assure you of one thing: Weak, she is not. And that’s key.
The perception and/or reality of strength is by far the most important attribute a presidential candidate can possess. Which is why the Trump campaign had been on a sugar high as it faced off against Biden, who seemed progressively more frail and—as Trump once famously tagged Florida governor Jeb Bush—“low energy.” Largely due to the ravages of age, Biden was always going to be seen as the weaker candidate.
But Harris—in contrast to the meandering, 78-year-old, culturally-ossified-in-the-1980s ex-president—appears youthful, energetic, and feisty. And anyone who’s watched her at all knows she does not back down from a fight. Sure, she deserves much of the criticism she got for her 2020 campaign; it was often lackluster. But she can be devastating when it matters. Recall how she hit Biden with an almost fatal roundhouse during one of the debates, lashing out at him for his efforts to oppose school busing.
With that in mind, there’s going to be a hell of a run on popcorn for the Harris-Trump debate—or debates. Trump was all in when his sparring partner was Biden. Now, apparently, Trump is already grousing about a September commitment, whining rather predictably that the next debate host should be Fox News, not ABC. And Harris, gunning for a fight, has already adopted Trump’s mantra against Old Joe: anytime, anywhere, as often as possible.
So, why the underestimation of Harris? Her 2020 campaign is one reason. Five and a half years ago, she stumbled out of the blocks. And yet, in politics, there’s nothing like getting your clock cleaned to learn some important lessons. It’s already clear from her new staffing moves that she’s not going to turn the ship over to friends and sycophants. Instead, she’s enlisting hardened pros like Jen O’Malley Dillon and, some say, the Obi-Wan Kenobi of the 2008 Obama campaign, David Plouffe.
And then—to go along with her political savvy—the vice president has her experience, her career arc, and those psychological, social, and personal attributes, which I’ve observed up close.
Honed as a prosecutor, time-tested by her countless public appearances, and charming in private, she’s now proving to be a formidable adversary on the stump—and the perfect spokesperson to make the case against Trump. Her speeches this past week have been masterfully cogent, and sometimes blistering, indictments of the GOP ticket, highlighting the hypocrisy of her rivals, who, despite being in the pockets of the privileged, are running as champions of the working class.
Those who have lowered expectations of Harris will be in for a jolt. Such prejudices (by which I mean both prejudgment and inexcusable bias) may well work in her favor. They’ll allow her to outperform her opponents and the presuppositions of the pundits—which, in politics, often translates into connection with voters.
Politically, the main advantage of being underestimated is that opponents don’t take you as seriously as they should. So they aren’t prepared when you show up and exceed expectations. Ask Al Gore, for example, about underestimating George W. Bush in their debates in 2000—a mistake that arguably cost him the election.
Strength, as I mentioned, is important. But in today’s cynical world, in which no one trusts anything, authenticity is also incredibly powerful and compelling. I’ve had the chance to interview Harris and found her to be open, engaging, warm, funny, and very human. I guess it’s just a reflection of the polarity of the times that one of the things Republicans seem to find most objectionable about her is the thing I love the most: her laugh. It’s genuine. Bring. It. On.
The great Peggy Noonan, the columnist and former Reagan speechwriter, captures and reflects the emerging Harris zeitgeist—and the perils of prejudgment. “Ms. Harris has not, in five years on the national stage, shown competence,” notes Noonan. “She is showing it now, and that is big news. Her rollout this week demonstrated talent and hinted she may be a real political athlete.”
Which highlights a very crucial point in modern politics: It is important, in the constant media glare, to be able to flip an additional switch when the lights go on. Harris didn’t just fall out of a coconut tree. She’s been working at this for a long, long time. Getting better and better. And now she’s showing her chops in prime time.
Don’t underestimate the power of performance. Harris reminds me of a Hall of Fame political performer I used to work for: Texas governor Ann Richards. It was Richards who famously remarked, “After all, Ginger Rogers did everything that Fred Astaire did. She just did it backwards and in high heels.”
Let the dance begin.
More Great Stories From Vanity Fair
Inside Kamala Harris’s Loyal Circle of Hollywood Friends
Peter Thiel, J.D. Vance, and the Dangerous Dance of the New Right
The Untold Stories of Humphrey Bogart’s Volatile Life
The Truth About Meghan, Harry, and Their California Dream
Inside California’s Freedom-Loving, Bible-Thumping Hub of Hard Tech
The Best TV Shows of 2024, So Far
Listen Now: VF’s Still Watching Podcast Dissects House of the Dragon